Food allergies are seen in up to 1 in 12 school-age children
in the United States today, and peanut is one of the most common
allergens. In response, many schools
have started to have peanut-free policies, but the effect of these policies has
not yet been rigorously assessed. In
this month’s issue of JACI, Bartnikas and colleagues examine how peanut-free
policies affect the rate of potentially fatal allergic reactions to peanut (J Allergy Clin Immunol 2017; 140(2): 465-473). They looked at 2,223 public schools in
Massachusetts during a five-year period, of which 6.3-10.3% banned peanuts from
being brought from home, 56.6-59.1% banned peanuts from being served in school,
90.1-91.1% had peanut-free tables and 65.6-67.4% had peanut-free classrooms. Among these schools, 46 (1.5-2.9%)
self-designated as being a “peanut-free school,” but there was considerable
variability in how these schools defined a self-designated “peanut-free school,”
with 28.9% still allowing peanuts to be brought from home and 4.4% not providing
peanut-free tables or classrooms. In the five-year study, 149 students had
peanut or tree-nut exposure that required epinephrine, of which two were in
self-designated peanut-free schools and one was in a school that did not
self-designate as peanut-free but banned peanuts from both being brought from
home and served by school.
What they found is that schools with peanut-free tables have
lower rates of epinephrine administration, presumably because of fewer life-threatening
allergic reactions. Epinephrine
administration rates were not significantly different in schools that had
policies restricting peanuts from home, served in schools, or having
peanut-free classrooms compared to those that didn’t have such policies. No
policy resulted in complete absence of allergic reactions.
The investigators do note that there are limitations to
their study. There may be variability in
how policies are interpreted and enforced and not all allergic reactions may have
been accounted for if they were not treated with epinephrine. Nevertheless, this study provides the first
evidence to help guide schools in drafting policies regarding peanuts to help
better safeguard children with peanut allergy.